The Reaper's Hideout is at the co-ordinates I-12 and I-13 on your map, and the Masked Stranger is on the Southern-most island, a shadowy woman in a hood. So if you were hoping to drop them off at the local trader's shop you'll be sadly disappointed, as they won't know what to do with it. You can only sell these kinds of Chests and Bounties to the Masked Stranger at The Reaper's Hideout, not at any other island, outpost or landmark. | Joel Franey/USgamer, Rare/Xbox Game Studios Where to Sell Or Turn In Reaper's Chest and Reaper's Bounty Treasures Reaper's Chests are valuable, but only to the right person. The most common thing you'll likely find under the Beacon is a shipwreck with the treasure inside, though Reaper's loot can be found also in the Fort of the Damned, from certain Mercenary Voyages and from certain quests that can be randomly dropped by skeleton bosses. The moment a player picks it up for the first time, the Beacon will disappear, though it will still be marked on your map table as a red skull, both before and after somebody claims it, so if you want to steal it from another crew you just need to follow that icon. The only guarantee we can give you about the lights is that they'll be an unclaimed Reaper's Chest or Reaper's Bounty at the bottom of them.
| Joel Franey/USgamer, Rare/Xbox Game Studios What's Under the Swirling Lights? The Beacon glowing the horizon, visible from any point in the map. As you might've guessed, the sheer pomp and ceremony created by these little boxes means that they might be worth a lot of money. These Beacons mark a very specific kind of treasure: either as a "Reaper's Chest", which is marked by red and green, or a "Reaper's Bounty", which created the golden lights. Seeing as these lights technically have no official name, we'll call them Beacons, which you'll see as either gold or a mix or red and green, depending on what kind of Beacon it is. What Are the Swirling Green, Red and Gold Lights on the Horizon?